DISCLAIMER: The following unofficial case summaries are prepared by the clerk's office
as a courtesy to the reader. They are not part of the opinion of the court.
032487P.pdf 06/02/2004 Heather Burton v. Patricia Richmond
U.S. Court of Appeals Case No: 03-2487
Western District of Missouri
Civil case - civil rights. Division of Family Services employees were
entitled to immunity on claims their failure to conduct a background
check or act to remove children following allegations of sexual abuse
violated plaintiffs' civil rights, as the agency never had custody or control
of the children and the danger to the children was created by the family
when they made the custodial arrangements which placed the children;
DFS's role was to help the family obtain legal recognition of custody
arrangements the family had already made, and recommending to the
juvenile officer the placement agreed to by the family was not sufficient
to create a duty to protect the children while they were in the placement;
under the circumstances, defendants' failure to investigate the allegations
of abuse was not so outrageous or egregious that it shocks the conscience
and amounts to a violation of plaintiffs' substantive due process rights;
failure to conduct a home study was no more than negligence and could
not serve as the basis for a claim that constitutional rights were violated;
even if plaintiffs had shown a constitutional violation, defendants were
still entitled to qualified immunity because the alleged rights they assert
were not clearly established in 1985 when the complained-of conduct
occurred.
[PUBLISHED][Bowman, Author, with Loken, Chief Judge and Fagg,
Circuit Judge]