DISCLAIMER: The following unofficial case summaries are prepared by the clerk's office
as a courtesy to the reader. They are not part of the opinion of the court.
033841P.pdf 05/13/2005 Charles Jess Palmer v. Harold W. Clarke
U.S. Court of Appeals Case No: 03-3841
and No: 03-3842
District of Nebraska
Habeas Case - Death Penalty. Claims upon which district court denied
habeas relief are affirmed: application of modified state's marital
privilege rule to third conviction did not violate ex post facto and the
state court's disposition of claim was not contrary to nor an unreasonable
application of federal law; change in rule was not a bill of attainder;
double jeopardy claim was successive claim and must be dismissed; 17-
week delay in retrial was not presumptively prejudicial and thus did not
violate the Speedy Trial Act; admission of identification by victim's wife
did not violate due process or other constitutional protections; and claim
that death by electrocution is cruel and unusual was procedurally
defaulted. Claims upon which district court's partially granted habeas
corpus relief are reversed. State court's proportionality review is not
subject to federal review; claim that defendant was deprived of two-tier
process was procedurally defaulted; State court's reformulation and
reweighing of aggravating and mitigating circumstances was sufficient to
justify imposition of death penalty even though exceptional depravity
aggravating circumstance was vague; defendant was not deprived of fair
notice; Ring claim was foreclosed by Supreme Court's decision in Schriro
v. Summerlin; death penalty is satisfied by conviction for felony murder
because defendant actually killed victim; ineffective assistance of counsel
claim from deficiency