041088P.pdf   04/11/2005  Taylor Corp.  v.  Four Seasons
   U.S. Court of Appeals Case No:  04-1088
   District of Minnesota   
   Civil case - Intellectual property. Adopting the majority view of the 
   other circuits, the court holds the appropriate standard for reviewing a 
   district court's findings of substantial similarity in copyright law cases is 
   clear error; district court correctly determined bankruptcy court order 
   constituted a transfer of ownership interests by operation of law to 
   plaintiff, and plaintiff owned the copyrights in the greeting cards at issue 
   in this case; district court's finding that the cards defendant produced 
   were substantially similar to plaintiff's trademarked cards was not clearly 
   erroneous; despite the availability of uncontested damages, plaintiff was 
   entitled to seek only injunctive relief; permanent injunction served the 
   public interest, and the district court did not err in permanently enjoining 
   defendant from violating the trademarks; defendant was not entitled to a 
   jury trial on plaintiff's action seeking only a permanent injunction. 
   [PUBLISHED] [Riley, Author, with Loken, Chief Judge, and M. Arnold, 
   Circuit Judge]