DISCLAIMER: Any unofficial case summaries below are prepared by the clerk's office
as a courtesy to the reader. They are not part of the opinion of the court.
062193P.pdf 02/27/2007 David J. Wood v. Valley Forge Ins.
U.S. Court of Appeals Case No: 06-2193
U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Arkansas - Little Rock
[PUBLISHED] [Arnold, Author, with Murphy and Benton,
Circuit Judges]
Civil case - Insurance. District court did not err
in rejecting insurer's claim that the policy was void
ab initio because of insured's misrepresentations at
the time the policy was issued; at most, the policy
was voidable within two years of issuance and since
the policy had been in effect for more than two years
at the time the insured died, the incontestability
clause of the policy precluded any attempt to rescind
the contract; the Arkansas Supreme Court would
require proximate cause in order for the sickness or
disease exclusion to relieve the insurer of liability
under an accidental death policy; here, the insured's
drug addiction and depression are too remote to be
considered the proximate cause of his death from an
drug and alcohol overdose; the district court erred
in redacting the insured's death certificate to
remove the coroner's conclusion that the insured's
death was a suicide, but the error was harmless as
the insurer was able to produce other evidence that
the death should be considered a suicide; jury
instructions requiring insurer to prove that the
death was suicide were proper statements of Arkansas
law which places that burden on an insurer trying to
defeat coverage under a suicide exclusion;
instructions requiring insurer to prove that insured
intended his death at the time he took the drugs and
alcohol were correct.