DISCLAIMER: Any unofficial case summaries below are prepared by the clerk's office
as a courtesy to the reader. They are not part of the opinion of the court.
073478P.pdf 04/09/2009 Michael Littleton v. Brandon McNeely
U.S. Court of Appeals Case No: 07-3478
U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri - Jefferson City
[PUBLISHED] [Riley, Author, with Bowman and Colloton, Circuit Judges]
Civil case - torts. Under Missouri law, the critical inquiries as to
whether operator's negligence could be imputed to owner-passenger of
the boat was not whether the owner had equal control at the time of the
accident but whether he had the right of control and whether an agency
relation existed between the operator and the owner; here, the undisputed
facts were sufficient to establish, as a matter of law, that principal-agent
relationship exited between the operator and the owner-passenger and
that the operator's negligence should be imputed to the owner as a matter
of law; as a result, the district court erred in denying McNeely's motion
for judgment as a matter of law; no error in excluding certain photos or in
precluding McNeely from referring to an area at the lake known as "Party
Cove;" district court did not err in allowing passenger's counsel to argue
his client did not have any alcohol in her bloodstream based on
emergency room blood analysis after the accident; district court did not
err in refusing McNeely's instruction concerning operator's intoxication;
no error in excluding evidence that operator allegedly violated Missouri
law prohibiting operation of a boat while intoxicated; no error in
excluding proposed expert testimony on other jurisdictions' blood alcohol
standards.