DISCLAIMER: The following unofficial case summaries are prepared by the clerk's office
as a courtesy to the reader. They are not part of the opinion of the court.
082147P.pdf 04/23/2009 Robert Hunt, Jr. v. Robert Houston
U.S. Court of Appeals Case No: 08-2147
District of Nebraska - Lincoln
[PUBLISHED] [Wollman, Author, with Bye and Riley, Circuit Judges]
Prisoner case - habeas. District court erred in its handling of a claim
related to prosecutor's misconduct, as the Nebraska Supreme Court
determined the claim was defaulted because it had not been raised in
Hunt's first habeas; in order to overcome a state procedural default
finding, Hunt must show either that the ruling resulted from an exorbitant
application of an otherwise sound rule, which he had not, or cause and
prejudice; Hunt had knowledge of all of the facts surrounding his claim
of prosecutorial misconduct, and he could not establish cause for his
failure to include it in his first post-conviction filings; nor could Hunt
establish prejudice because the statements related to the misconduct were
not admitted at trial (the prosecutor removed information that Hunt had
requested counsel at the end of his first statement, thereby making the
admissibility of his second statement problematical; however, the state
told the court and Hunt before trial that it would not introduce the second
statement and it did not use the statement at trial); trial counsel's failure
to adequately investigate the conduct and report it to ethics authorities did
not result in any prejudice; the possibility of prejudice is further undercut
by the strength of the state's case, and Hunt has failed to show that there
is a reasonable probability that the outcome of his trial would have been
different; claim that his trial counsel's closing arguments amounted to a
complete denial of Hunt's right to counsel was properly rejected by the
district court; claim that the state court improperly admitted evidence as a
result of the second statement was properly rejected; grant of habeas
relief is reversed, and the matter is remanded with directions to dismiss
the petition.