112068P.pdf   07/17/2012  Julio Matul-Hernandez  v.  Eric H. Holder, Jr.
   U.S. Court of Appeals Case No:  11-2068
   Appeal from Board of Immigration Appeals   
   [PUBLISHED] [Wollman, Author, with Colloton and Benton, Circuit Judges]
   Petition for Review - Immigration. The IJ's finding that petitioner had
   not suffered past persecution was supported by substantial evidence; the
   BIA's finding that Guatemalans returning from the U.S. who are
   perceived as wealthy did not constitute a particular and socially visible
   group such that they could be perceived as a group and targeted for
   persecution was supported by substantial evidence; the agency did not err
   in finding that petitioner did not show a well-founded fear of persecution
   upon return to Guatemala on account of his membership in a particular
   social group; withholding of removal was properly denied as petitioner
   did not meet the less rigorous test for asylum; CAT claim was raised for
   the first time on appeal and would not be considered on appeal.