161341P.pdf   03/07/2017  Dennis Ryan, Jr.  v.  Officer Mary Armstrong
   U.S. Court of Appeals Case No:  16-1341
   U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota - Minneapolis   
   [PUBLISHED] [Murphy, Author, with Loken and Kelly, Circuit Judges] 
   Civil case - Civil rights. The plaintiff estate's deceased died while in 
   custody at the Stearns County Jail, and the estate brought this action for 
   violation of the deceased's civil rights; the district court erred in 
   granting defendants summary judgment on plaintiff's deliberate 
   indifference claim, as a reasonable factfinder could conclude that the 
   deceased was suffering from an obvious medical need and that the failure 
   to speak with him or seek medical treatment was a clearly inadequate 
   response that supports an inference of deliberate indifference 
   constituting a violation of constitutional rights; the district court 
   erred in finding that defendants Armstrong and Colluton were entitled to 
   to qualified immunity given the factors supporting a finding of deliberate 
   indifference and the case law which shows that it was clearly established 
   at the time of the incident that a pretrial detainee like the deceased has 
   a right to be free from deliberately indifferent denials of emergency 
   medical care; defendants were entitled to summary judgment on the estate's 
   excessive force claim as the evidence showed that none of the defendants' 
   actions, either singly or in combination, amounted to an objectively 
   unreasonable application of force; defendants' summary judgment on failure 
   to train is reversed in light of the court's ruling on the deliberate 
   indifference claim; dismissal of the trustee's state law claims is also 
   reversed. Judge Loken, concurring in part and dissenting in part.