202417P.pdf   08/04/2021  Gemma  Rosales-Reyes  v.  Merrick B. Garland
   U.S. Court of Appeals Case No:  20-2417
   Petition for Review of an Order of the Board of Immigration Appeals   
   [PUBLISHED] [Shepherd, Author, with Gruender and Benton, Circuit Judges] 
   Petition for Review - Immigration. The agency did not err in finding that 
   petitioner's proposed social group - Mexican mothers who refuse to work 
   for the Cartel - was not sufficiently particularized or social distinct; 
   violence against a family member cannot establish persecution sufficient 
   for asylum because a pattern of persecution tied to the petitioner is 
   required; denial of asylum is affirmed, and it follows that denial of 
   withholding of removal is also affirmed; with respect to CAT relief, 
   petitioner could safely relocate by joining her parents in a Mexican state 
   free from the Cartel's control and, therefore, she was not entitled to CAT 
   relief.