203088P.pdf   03/11/2022  Simon Osagi Iyawe  v.  Merrick B. Garland
   U.S. Court of Appeals Case No:  20-3088
   U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota   
   [PUBLISHED] [Kelly, Author, with Colloton and Shepherd, Circuit Judges] 
   Civil Case - Petition for Alien Relative. Alicia Iyawe appeals from the 
   denial of her I-130 Petition for Alien Relative on behalf of her husband, 
   Simon, a citizen of Nigeria. Four prior I- 130 petitions filed by two 
   former spouses were denied based on determinations that the marriages were 
   for the purposes of evading immigration laws and thus fraudulent. Alicia's 
   petition was thus denied. The Board of Immigration Appeals affirmed on 
   appeal. On review in district court under the Administrative Procedures 
   Act, the agency's decision was neither arbitrary, capricious or an abuse 
   of discretion. The government gave adequate consideration to the evidence 
   in the record and reasonably gave greater weight to some evidence. There 
   was no clear error of judgment in the BIA's final determination that there 
   was substantial and probative evidence of marriage fraud.